First the 300 star was linked to John's ex Jennifer Aniston, and now the New York Post claims he had a date with Jessica Simpson, who also dated the "Daughters" singer. The Butler/Simpson hookup, which took place at New York City's SoHo House, is definitely in the early stages, especially since they were chaperoned by Jess' best friend and hairstylist Ken Paves. But it sure sounds like the two stars were into each other. "They were at a table with friends, but Jessica and Gerard, who sat next to each other, seemed to only be interested in each other and chatted for hours," said a source. "They were laughing and flirting and eventually left together, along with Ken."